Judge on Pamela Smart's New Bid: You Said This 30 Years Ago

NH judge rejects request to overturn conviction, says long-standing bias claims were addressed in appeals
Posted Sep 18, 2026 9:30 AM CDT
Judge Denies Pamela Smart's New Bid to Overturn Conviction
This image taken from video in Concord, New Hampshire, shows Pamela Smart appearing remotely from Bedford Hills Correctional Facility in Bedford Hills, New York, on July 20.   (Merrimack County Superior Court via AP, file)

Pamela Smart just hit another legal dead end. A New Hampshire judge has turned down her latest bid to unravel the conviction that's kept her in prison for the 1990 killing of her husband, Gregg Smart, reports WMUR. In a habeas corpus petition submitted in January that sought a new trial and sentencing, Smart's lawyers argued that jurors were given flawed transcripts of low-quality audio recordings that could've skewed what they thought they heard. Merrimack County Superior Court James Kennedy, however, pointed out that similar complaints were raised and rejected more than three decades ago during the appeals process, adding that Smart, now 59, still hasn't shown specific inaccuracies that harmed her case.

The court also brushed aside other claims, including that her lawyer effectively admitted her guilt, that media coverage tainted the verdict, and that the mandatory sentence was wrongly imposed—leaving her life-without-parole conviction intact. William Flynn, the teen who was having an affair with Smart and gunned down her husband, and three other teens who helped with the plot offered their cooperation to prosecutors and have all since been released from prison, per the AP. Court TV notes that even though the murder took place in New Hampshire, Smart is serving her sentence in New York, due to an arrangement between the two states. A New York court determined that a similar motion she'd filed there didn't fall under its jurisdiction.

Read These Next
Get the news faster.
Tap to install our app.
X
Install the Newser News app
in two easy steps:
1. Tap in your navigation bar.
2. Tap to Add to Home Screen.

X
More News: Sports | Business | Entertainment | Politics | Tech